How well do students in secondary school understand temporal development of dynamical systems?
2015 European Journal of Science and Mathematics Education Cilt 2015/3, Sayı 2
İngilizce öz
Despite difficulties understanding the dynamics of complex systems only simple dynamical systems without feedback
connections have been taught in secondary school physics. Consequently, students do not have opportunities to
develop intuition of temporal development of systems, whose dynamics are conditioned by the influence of feedback
processes. We present a research study on students' understanding of temporal development of simple dynamical
systems. Students participating in the study were attending the final two years of a technical secondary school
(gimnazija) program. Based on written equations for the rate of change of some quantity students had to qualitatively
determine dynamical development. The study confirmed the initial hypotheses with regard to poor knowledge in the
area of dynamical systems, irrelevant of year in secondary school or final grade in physics or mathematics. The results
showed that most students understood the development of linear systems without feedback and based on equations,
students were able to forecast the dynamical development of changing quantities. Issues arose in understanding
systems with feedback connections that influence the nonlinear dynamical development of changing quantity.
Especially with negative feedback connections that provide stabilization of changing quantities. The reason could be
that in most of the cases they turned towards linear dynamical development of changing quantities. Frequently, they
incorrectly concluded that the temporal development of changing quantities is the same to temporal development of
current, which determines the state of quantity. As a response in overcoming such issues, we recommend a geometrical
consideration of one-dimensional dynamical systems.